top of page

The prosecution problem revisited - again!

Further to my recent blog on the limits of prosecutions (The prosecution problem revisited), the prosecution summary of the first case dealing with Wesley Ballantine's death at work has been published, The case follows a very familiar pattern:

  1. Two and a half year delay;

  2. Guilty plea;

  3. Penalty - 9% of the maximum; and

  4. No lessons learned.

This is not the Court's fault. All of the processes and findings seems entirely consistent with existing legal principles.


But is adds no value to improving workplace safety.


And I am at a loss to understand how Industrial Manslaughter, or any other penalty regime would have made any difference to the safety on that work site. Although, as I said in my last article, it appears industrial manslaughter has nothing to do with improved safety outcomes - only administrative convenience and public outcry.


But more practically, on reading the case summary, if we cannot start to have a discussion about gross negligence in these circumstances, then in all likelihood, the bar for industrial manslaughter will be set too high to ever act as a practical deterrent.


The case is entirely consistent with decades of failed, bureaucratic, administrative approaches to safety. Everything in place and documented - nothing done to manage the actual hazards. This is the problem in modern safety management, and this case is another missed opportunity to understand why "theoretical" safety ideas and paperwork failed in practice.


This is a case that demanded a proper inquiry, not a prosecution process.


This was an opportunity to bring together experts to try and understand the abject failure of the modern safety approach.


At the core of my objection to industrial manslaughter is simple intellectual laziness. Lets just keep doing the same old thing in the same way and see what happens. We know what happens - young men like Wesley will continue to die at work.


We do not need a change in penalties, we need a change in our entire approach - an outdated approach based on 1970's understanding of people and workplaces.


Health and safety needs genuine disruption, not more of the same.





8 Comments


Win info
Win info
May 29

Great job securing the win! It may not have been the flashiest victory, but you stayed focused and delivered when it mattered most. That kind of steady performance shows real potential. Keep pushing forward and building on this success — every win counts, and this one is another step in the right direction. Proud of the consistency! ok win

Like

hasan
May 16

It seems like Worlock Air Conditioning & Heating is really focused on providing comprehensive AC solutions across the Phoenix metro area! Highlighting energy-saving systems and tailoring recommendations to Peoria's specific climate are great ways to serve their customers. ac replacement peoria az

Like

Looking for the best betting experience? Try Mahadev Book! Get instant access and top-notch support with your Mahadev Book id .Fast payouts, exciting games, and real-time updates await you.Join thousands who trust Mahadev Book for seamless betting fun!

Visit now - https://mahadevbooks.digital/


Like


Baterybet offers a smooth and exciting platform for online sports betting.The battery bet interface is user-friendly and perfect for quick navigation.If you're into reliable betting, Baterybet is a top choice in the market.With secure battery bet login, users enjoy a safe and private experience.Visit now- https://batery.ind.in/

For more details visit on- https://batery.ind.in/

Like

cricbettt
May 05

CricBet99 is your trusted destination for cricket-focused sports insights and predictions. With real-time match data and expert betting tips, it delivers an edge in every game. The cricbet99  is designed for seamless user experience and reliable updates. Sign in through cricbet99 login to start your winning journey today.

 Visit now - https://cricbets99.ind.in/


Like
bottom of page